NVLindaGuerita: haha ay Dominic, Y0U Would!! lmao. RT @KING_DBOi: If she doesn't like the yankees or the cowboys.. #notgirlfriendmaterial
about 3 minutes ago
D0NTBEAH8T3R: RT @KING_DBOi: If she doesn't like the yankees or the cowboys.. #notgirlfriendmaterial < dam RIGHT!!!!
about 7 minutes ago
BR_Yankees: Should The Yankees Trade For Halladay Or Look Somewhere Else?: The best moves are sometimes the ones you don't make... link
about 7 minutes ago
KING_DBOi: If she doesn't like the yankees or the cowboys.. #notgirlfriendmaterial
about 8 minutes ago
bdobbs23: #redsox fans, Granderson to NYY could leave the #yankees out of the bidding for Bay or Holliday. Would that be a positive for the Sox? Hmm.
about 10 minutes ago
Follow us on Twitter ...
 |
Keeping Sabathia will be tough enough without the newspaper writing out-of-context headlines. |
 | By Andy Tarnoff   Publisher Photography by Allen Fredrickson E-mail author | Author bio More articles by Andy Tarnoff |
| Published Nov. 19, 2008 at 11:59 a.m. |
|
As if trying to sign CC Sabathia wasn't hard enough, it looks like the local paper may have helped make the Brewers' task a little harder this week.
Sunday's Journal Sentinel ran a story titled, "Yankees' offer baffles Melvin," though at no point does it quote Brewers General Manager saying that he was in any way baffled. Instead, it quotes Melvin saying, "It sounds like they're overbidding. If the speculation is true that we've offered CC $100 million, why would you offer $140 million? Why wouldn't you offer $110 million?"
Now, MLB.com's Adam McCalvy is reporting that Melvin hasn't heard back from the Sabathia's representatives. Maybe it's because they think the Brewers are "baffled" -- and not ready to step up and negotiate.
McCalvy wrote, "Melvin admitted he got a fair amount of reaction for his comment last week that the Yankees were 'overbidding' for Sabathia by exceeding the Brewers' offer -- the only other formal overture to Sabathia reported so far -- by such a significant amount. He took issue with a headline on a Milwaukee Journal Sentinel report that said he was 'baffled' by the Yankees' offer."
"I wasn't baffled by what they are doing," Melvin told McCalvy. "I do think it's funny that the Yankees make their bid, and a couple of hours later it's on ESPN."
Hey Journal Sentinel, the Yankees don't need any additional help in poaching Sabathia. Please stick to the quotes and skip the editorializing in your headlines. Melvin's job right now is hard enough -- the last thing he needs is to have a newspaper start putting words in his mouth.
One Miller Park Way
Milwaukee, WI 53214
(414) 902-4000
http://brewers.com
|
9 comments about this article. Post a comment / write a review. |
Recent Talkbacks ...
Posted by brewguru on Nov. 24, 2008 at 11:01 a.m. (report)
Doesn't matter what the headline said, Melvin still sounded like a whinining, sniveling little baby that the big, bad Yankees were outbidding them. He knew going in that the Santana contract would be the minimum bid for Sabathia. Step up to the plate or go home.
| Rate this: |
Posted by upofan on Nov. 20, 2008 at 11:13 a.m. (report)
When you have the deepest pockets...there is no such thing as overbidding. Especially when you can afford to go after Lowe and Burnett too. Baby Stein is trying to make his mark on the franchise.
| Rate this: |
Posted by viewfromnyave on Nov. 20, 2008 at 8:14 a.m. (report)
I follow Melvin's way of thinking on this one. The Yankees, at this point, basically have outbid themselves in the tune of, I would think, at least $20M. The Brewers offer $100M and the Yanks come back with $140M. Why didn't they just offer $120M? That's an extra $20M on the table, probably enough to offset any sort of discount he'd give the Brewers. Now what happens when CC comes back to the Yankees and says, "Nah, the Giants offered $130M, you'll have to go to $150 for me to waive the hometown discount". By initially going to $140M, the Yankees artificially set the bidding higher than it would have normally been set. Whatever, it's Steinbrenner's money, but it just didn't seem like a real bright negotiating technique. My only guess is that they thought they'd bowl over CC and he'd sign without listening to anybody else. But what agent would fall for that?
| Rate this: |
Posted by mikeb on Nov. 19, 2008 at 5:16 p.m. (report)
C'mon Andy, you know enough about baseball to know what the market for CC was going to be. I'm not a major league GM and even I could figure out that some team would offer CC a contract in line with the deal the Mets gave to Johan Santana last year. The Yankees have done exactly that. I'm not sure how Doug could think this was overbidding unless he's unaware of Santana's deal. If the fact that a team offered a deal like this causes Melvin to believe they are overbidding then he comes across as "baffled" to me. If the Brewers really wanted CC they should have offered a $100,000,000 deal at 4 years. Sure, it would not have been as much as the best bid would be, but it would be for one less year and allow CC to be a free agent again at 31. This is all about public perception. The Brewers want to make it seem like they are doing all they can to resign CC when they know their offer was not going to be anywhere near what the market would bear. I'm not sure it's a great idea to sign Sabathia, but seeing as though we'll be paying the trio of Cameron, Suppan and Hall $28,000,000 next year I'd be open to it as CC is actually a difference maker. Teams get into trouble when they give big money to marginal guys like Cameron, Hall and Soup and while it is risky to offer CC a massive deal you also know that he's capable of winning 8 or 9 more games than the average guy.
| Rate this: |
Posted by AJStanislaw on Nov. 19, 2008 at 3:40 p.m. (report)
Don't ever look to the Journal/Sentinal for anything more than 24 hour Green Bay Packer pumping. That's all they know.
| Rate this: |
Show me the other 4 Talkbacks
Recent blogs/briefs by Andy Tarnoff
|
A gift a day: 500 GB DVR expander Sunday You already know that DVRs are awesome. They change the way you watch TV. They make every ... |
|
Let's get realistic about Afghanistan Dec. 03, 2009 Obama can't win, when it comes to the war on terror. He can't "win" the war in Afghanistan, ... |
|
Plenty of good Packers plates still available Nov. 30, 2009 Personalized Packers vanity plates aren't cheap. Fortunately, there are ample combination ... |
|
You can dance if you want to Nov. 30, 2009 I went to the wedding on Saturday night of one of my wife's best friends. The reception, ... |
|
Has Google's stance on neutrality gone too far? Nov. 25, 2009 The Web is buzzing about an offensive and crude Photoshopping of Michelle Obama that, ... |
| Top Clicks | Top Searches | Most Talkbacks |
- Saturday Scorecard: A crucial holiday shopping trip
- Saying "farewell" to a trusty daily companion
- Yankees' success is proof Brewers are a lost cause
- Hardy trade just the beginning
- Hardy traded to Minnesota, Brewers get CF Gomez
- With World Series over, Brewers will get to work
- Taking a mini-vacation at the Fall Classic
- Brewers' brass meets the press
- Monday musings: October 2009 edition
- Brewers notebook: Macha will be back in 2010
