Milwaukee's Daily Magazine Tuesday, Dec. 1, 2009
Today
Hi: 51
Lo: 35
Wed
Hi: 42
Lo: 32
Thu
Hi: 38
Lo: 21
Section Sponsor
Article Tools
Print this Article
Make text larger
Related Twitter Posts

  • ChibiRuby:
    Good or Bad? Pullout From Afghanistan to Begin in 2011, Officials Say - link

  • kindcutesteve:
    Iran 2 free all foreign hostages, political prisoners or West will arrest AH & officials traveling outside Iran & in Embassies #iranelection

  • vincentngo:
    8: If I don't respond it's not because I hate you, I might just be busy with my new challenges or I just want a little privacy.

  • iaoth:
    @AquariusPoetry Oh, I hear you. I have zero discipline. I shun responsibilities though, I'm fine without challenges and change. (Or am I?)

  • TOIAhemdabad:
    Probe against cops accused in oil pilferage scam start: Senior police officials who are or were once posted in... link


Follow us on Twitter ...
In Sports Commentary
Upon further review ... Czabe issues a challenge
Texas A&M didn't get a call on this pivotal play...
By Steve Czaban RSS Feed
Special to OnMilwaukee.com

E-mail author | Author bio
More articles by Steve Czaban

Published March 25, 2008 at 5:21 a.m.
Tags: ncaa tournament, officials, challenges, czaban, bobby knight

(page 2)

Furthermore, Sloan almost was knocked flat on his back, another sign that the ball was not poked away cleanly.

Alas, being a virtual home game for UCLA, with the crowd in full roar, and the misguided cliché of "let the players determine the game" being so prevalent today, the refs swallowed their whistles.

And the Aggies had to sulk home in defeat.

Had instant replay been in effect, A&M could have challenged the non-call. If replays were conclusive -- and I think they would have been -- then it's easy to ignore what followed and stop the clock at the moment of the foul and award the free throws.

Would this lead to "chaos" and "four-hour games" as some have derided me for suggesting?

Not in the least.

I said: ONE challenge per game. Period!

OK, what if a foul is called, a team challenges it and they are correct, what then?

Easy: jump ball. You can't assume possession on a foul that was reversed to be "not a foul," so you do the next best thing. Jump it up. It would discourage using your one challenge on a foul call anyway, since the best outcome is not nearly what using it on a non-call would be -- two free throws.

Plus, think of all the other worthy plays that might benefit from having this ONE challenge in your pocket. A ball knocked out of bounds on a late, key possession or guy stepping on the end line or sideline ...

How about the hardest call of them all: a block / charge?

Even with replay, you will still get controversy about calls NOT overturned when you swear they should be. But again, it's just ONE call per game. What is the harm in that?

The NCAA already uses replay for three-point attempts and shot clock violations. Why not expand it just a little? Even on a trial basis, what could it hurt?

As it stands, Texas A&M has no standing in the halls of college basketball royalty. Thus, the outrage on this is very mild, if it even exists at all.

But can you imagine if North Carolina got a non-call like this in the final against UCLA? Ty Lawson getting hammered like this to deny Roy Williams another championship would create a media firestorm like you've never seen.

Frankly, I'm surprised that the NCAA hasn't had a refereeing disaster of this order yet. Call me nuts, but I think a one-challenge per game replay rule would be worthy insurance against it.

If nothing else, see what Bobby Knight thinks of my idea.

<< Back

 Page 2 of 2 (view all on one page)


More Information ...
Related links:

3 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.

Recent Talkbacks ...

Posted by dotherightthing on March 25, 2008 at 11:14 p.m. (report)

Steve, you are absolutely CORRECT! Donald Sloan was hammered and hacked (CLEAR as a bell). He most likely would've tied the game..at least. Texas A&M would've most likely ended up winning; as they deserved! In all probability, if the Aggies wouldn't have won the game outright...it would have gone to OT and they would've won it there! As it stands, Texas A&M got royally hosed and the refs know they screwed them! Talk about dishonest and fixing a game!!!

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by Fan on March 25, 2008 at 12:19 p.m. (report)

Great idea. NBA too.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Posted by ccmerz on March 25, 2008 at 12:17 p.m. (report)

Okay, Czabe. You're nuts.

Rate this:
  • Average rating: 0.0
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5



OnMilwaukee.com is part of the In Click Network. Other In Click sites include: 30RockReport.com | Behind The Scenes at OnMilwaukee.com | BetterRecipes.org | Bimmer Digest | Brain Brawn & Body | BrewCityBeats.com | Brewcitybigscreen.com | britneysnation.com | BritPop Rocks | Brooklynbanter.com | CactusLeagueReport.com | Caffeinateddigest.com | Culinary Piedmont | Cycling Chainring | Daily Lost Update | Daily Milwaukee News | Daily Spa | DannyGokeyMilwaukee.com | Dogs Blogs | EarthFueled.com | Edible Wisconsin | FanaticPhotog.com | Gadget Deals and Steals | GolfLinksWisconsin.com | H1N1 Alerts | H1N1 Blog | H1N1 Prevention | H1N1 Reporter | H1N1 Tracker | HogEnthusiast.com | Informed Runner | iPhone Daily Report | Man United Nation | Milwaukee Brewers Nation | Milwaukee Bucks Blog | Milwaukee Dad | Minnesota Wild Nation | MomMilwaukee.com | My Super Stocks | MyGayMilwaukee.com | MyHangoverHelper | News on Draught | NY Mets Nation | OnAtlantaGA.com | OnAustinTX.com | OnBaltimoreMD.com | OnBirminghamAL.com | OnBostonMass.com | OnBuffaloNY.com | OnCharlotteNC.com | OnCincinnati.com | OnClevelandOH.com | OnColumbusOH.com | OnDallas.com | OnDCmetro.com | OnDenverCO.com | OnDetroitMI.com | OnDoorCounty.org | OnFortLauderdale.com | OnGreenBay.com | OnHartford.com | OnIndianapolisIN.com | OnKansasCityMO.com | OnLakeCountry.com | OnLosAngelesCA.com | OnLouisvilleKY.com | OnMadison.com | OnMemphisTN.com | OnMiamiFLA.com | OnMilwaukee.com Cars | OnMilwaukee.com Metro Headlines | OnNashvilleTN.com | OnNewOrleansLA.com | OnNYCny.com | OnOrlandoFL.com | OnPalmSprings.com | OnPhiladelphia.com | OnPhoenixAZ.com | OnPittsburgh.com | OnPortlandOR.com | OnProvidence.com | OnRichmondVA.com | OnSacramento.com | OnSaltLakeCity.com | OnSanAntonioTX.com | OnSanDiegoCA.com | OnSanFran.com | OnSanJose.com | OnSeattleWA.com | OnSinCity.com | OnStLouis.com | OnStPetersburg.com | OnTampaBay.com | OnTucsonAZ.com | OnTwinCities.com | OnWichita.com | OnWindyCity.com | Packers Posts | Porsche 911 Fans | PriusFans.com | Roller Derby Network | SnuggieFans.com | SummerfestRocks.com | Swine Flu China | Swine Flu Reporter | The 24 Reporter | The Barack Obama Fan Club | The Brilliant Manager | The Comic Book Reporter | The In Click | The Office Fan Blog | TheHDTVReporter.com | TheNetbookBlog.com | TheNewParentBlog.com | Trueguitarheroes.com | Vintage Mets | VW Busses | WaukeshaWeekly.com | Weekly Media News | Wisconsincustomhomenews.com | WisWomen.com | Woodworker Digest