The common stock shares for Kohl's Corp. rose 56 cents Thursday amid growing Wall Street speculation that the Menomonee Falls-based retailer could be a prime target to be acquired by a private equity firm in 2013.
Kohl's fell in January to its lowest valuation relative to revenue in more than four years after the retailer cut its profit forecasts because of disappointing holiday sales and steeper-than-planned price reductions, according to a report by Bloomberg.
Kohl's stock is trading at only 0.58 times its sales and at a cheaper multiple to profit than any other North American department-store chain, Bloomberg reported.
Stock analysts at Edward Jones & Co., Morningstar Inc., Aston Hill Financial Inc. and Delafield-based Arnold Investment Counsel each speculated with Bloomberg that Kohl's could be prime for a takeover.
Kohl's, with exclusive brands such as Jennifer Lopez and Vera Wang that help attract repeat customers, may be attractive to a company because of its extensive real estate holdings, including many stores that have been equipped with solar panels, the analysts said.
"It's a good, sound retailer," Brian Yarbrough, an analyst for Edward Jones in St. Louis, told Bloomberg. "There's been more talk of it being a private equity play because it's cheap and it's not like the model's broken or it's a bad business. The earnings power is there."
U.S. private equity funds have $360 billion of committed unspent capital dedicated to buyout funds in the global market, according to data from research firm Preqin Ltd.
Barry Arnold, a fund manager at Arnold Investment Counsel, which owns Kohl's shares, said, "There's plenty of cash sloshing around, so that's not a big problem...It's an attractive company."
Kohl's operates more than 1,100 stores across the United States and has annual sales of about $19 billion.
A spokeswoman for Kohl's did not respond to a phone call or e-mail seeking comment on the Bloomberg report.
If Kohl's is acquired by a private equity firm, it remains unclear whether that transaction would have an impact on the retailer's decision to build its new headquarters in Menomonee Falls, rather than downtown Milwaukee.
Sheer speculation here, but I've got to believe that an independent, fresh set of eyes from the outside would second-guess that decision and would come to the conclusion that the company's ability to recruit top talent in the future would be more enhanced with a downtown Milwaukee headquarters in the hub of it all, rather than an isolated campus in the suburbs.
Steve Jagler is executive editor of BizTimes Milwaukee.
perhaps Kohls is staying away from the City of Milwaukee as they "The City literally threw the kitchen sink at them the last time". I know that would keep me away.
If Milwaukee really did literally throw the kitchen sink at Kohls then I can understand why Menomonee Falls was selected.
I'm not sure what Kohl's decision to stay in Menomonee Falls has to do with this article.
The trouble with the business coverage in Milwaukee is that it seems the editors want to write on how they think business should be run and are preoccupied with trying to hang out with the cool kids rather than ask interesting questions or report news.
One great question to ask in the Kohl's story is why doesn't Kohl's, or for that matter any other company, want to locate in the Park East Area? Instead they go with the Jeff Sherman-esque "Target should come to the Grand Avenue" types of articles without exploring why no one wants to locate there.
The wanting to hang out with the cool kids thing is huge as well. Witness Mr. Jagler's valentine on OMC looking for new investors. It read like a promo rather than asking some interesting questions like "after 15 years why do you still need investors after we spent the whole article talking about how successful you are"
If you're a green company, a fresh water company or a creative, you'll get coverage. Maybe there's an interesting article there about the challenges and opportunities in digital media.
I suspect if Kohl's thought they needed to be downtown to attract the talent they needed, they would be downtown. Given that Mr. Jagler does not own a large company he might not realize that the twenty-something creatives aren't the main targets of most businesses. Rather they are usually looking for people a little bit older. Those people will be more likely to have kids and want to live in the suburbs.
When I started my career in 1997 downtown was the place to be. Gradually we've seen a shift to firms moving out west. When I first went off on my own I located in the third ward and had a decent experience, but it was clear that clients did not like coming down there for a variety of reasons. So we picked up and moved West.
There are some great stories to tell about Milwaukee's declining downtown and what can be done to reverse it, but I guess it's easier to simply report on what you'd like companies to do.
7,000 employees work at existing Kohls corperate. Most of them bought homes/condos in the area (especially the higher-ups). None of them (especially the ones that make the decisions) want to drive through rush-hour twice a day and pay $100/month for parking downtown. Never gonna happen. They only leaked the downtown option to get a better deal from Menomonee Falls. They should just turn the Park East into a park or a nature preserve.
Northwestern Mutual is investing $350,000 in their downtown Milwaukee headquarters. I think Kohls can probably figure out parking... And the cost of doing business in downtown would undoubtably be subsidized by a large TIF. The City literally threw the kitchen sink at them the last time.
No doubt they'd be much more attractive to the young talent they try and court from the Coasts in a dense cultural center rather than in the middle of nowhere suburbia (sorry Falls, but it's true).
Show me the other Talkback
6 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Steve Jagler
Published Oct. 19, 2014
Empower your people to think like entrepreneurs and serve your customers. That was the leading takeaway message from the panelists at the first Next Stage Workshop recently presented by BizTimes.
Published Oct. 8, 2014
The Council of Small Business Executives (COSBE) recently unveiled its list of the "Fastest Five" companies.
Published Sept. 17, 2014
Bottom line: Koss is losing money, has halted production at its plant in Mexico, is pulling back on research and development of new products and is suspending payment of dividends to shareholders.
Published July 23, 2014
If you do a Google search for the phrase "bowling is a dying sport," you will discover that folks have been predicting the demise of keggling since the dawn of the digital age.
Published July 18, 2014
The Milwaukee Cultural and Entertainment Capital Needs Task Force invited business leaders from Oklahoma City, Denver and Cleveland to discuss a new arena, mass transit and other infrastructure projects in Milwaukee.
Published July 9, 2014
Though it may seem counterintuitive, there are times when the customer is not worth the drama, and the customer must be fired.
Published June 25, 2014
Kay Plantes, an MIT-trained economist, author and expert on business model innovation, recently predicted the next big wave of innovation in health care.
Published June 11, 2014
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) recently voted to open up recently proposed rules concerning the future of the Internet for public comment. The changes could end net neutrality.
Published May 29, 2014
To many of my colleagues in the baby boom generation, the rising generation of millennials is a mystery.
Published May 15, 2014
Could Milwaukee-based Wisconsin Energy Corp. or Madison-based Aliant Energy Corp. become takeover targets for renowned investor Warren Buffett? Possibly, according to a new analysis by Bloomberg.