Talk about lofty goals.
"Life of Pi," director Ang Lee's adaptation of Yann Martel's 2001 bestselling novel, frames itself as the ultimate spiritual, religious adventure. Early on in the film, a character even states that he wants to hear a story that "will make you believe in God." If that wasn't enough, the movie's 3-D is supposed to revive audiences' pre-"Clash of the Titans" love for the gimmick. I don't know which feat would be more impressive.
So does "Life of Pi" have the emotional power to turn the religiously dubious into the devout? Eh, unlikely. Will it restore people's faith in 3-D? Possibly. If there's one thing that's undoubtedly confirmed after seeing Piscene Molitor Patel's sea-based saga, though, it's that Ang Lee is an outrageously talented and inventive visual director.
After setting the stage with a few stories about his unique name, school days and childhood religious experimentation, Pi Patel (Irrfan Khan) tells a struggling author (Rafe Spall, previously seen talking cutesy with a deadly alien snake in "Prometheus") his epic tale of survival.
In his story, teenage Pi (impressive newcomer Suraj Sharma) miraculously survives a violent ship sinking while moving from India to Canada with his family. He, as well as a few exotic animals from his family's zoo, find their way onto a lifeboat, but after a sad series of events, only Pi and a beautiful but ravenous Bengal tiger are left alive. Together, the two must learn to survive the elements, hunger, mysterious islands and each other to pass this fierce test of faith.
Most of what ensues consists only of Pi and the tiger, named Richard Parker due to a clerical error, floating out on the lonely sea. It sounds like it has the potential to be a bore, but Lee fills the adventure with gorgeous and vibrant images that keeps viewers excitedly anticipating what surreal imagery they'll see next.
A sinking ship's lights hauntingly illuminate the world under the ocean's surface. The lifeboat looks like it's floating in the midst of a vast, mesmerizing emptiness; the horizon is a mere myth. A school of jellyfish gives the night a florescent glow. The word visionary gets tossed around a lot nowadays when talking about directors (Zack Snyder and Sam Raimi have both dubiously received the title), but after "Life of Pi," Lee proves he's one of the few who deserve it.
The 3-D adds a surprising depth to Lee's already rich visuals. In fact, it's so immersive that it's easy to take it for granted. Things aren't popping out or shouting "look at the 3-D!" at the audience. Instead, it makes the ocean feel even more vast and the lifeboat even more alone.
There are a few moments where the gimmick missteps, most notably during a siege of flying fish where it abruptly adds letterboxing (that's not good 3-D; that's cheating). I wouldn't say you have to see it in 3-D; it's not like "Avatar" where if you see it 2-D, you're getting a worse movie. But overall, it's an impressive addition that won't have you feeling buyer's remorse for the $3 upcharge.
Lee is almost as capable with the film's story as he is with the magical visuals. "Life of Pi"'s story takes the audience through a lot, starting with Pi's charming childhood experiences, a short-but-sweet romance and then finally hitting the open seas. There, all sorts of intense moments – namely a shipwreck that could give "Titanic" a run for its money and the suspenseful interactions with the increasingly hungry Richard Parker – take place. All the while, religious debates, discussions and frustrations arise, all well presented and intriguing, even when the visuals aren't busy wowing the audience.
The only unfortunate thing is that, for a journey so entrenched in spirituality, survival and uplift, it's rather emotionally distant. Pi's story just never hits the soul as strongly as it should. A large chunk of the problem is the "Big Fish/Curious Case of Benjamin Button"-esque frame story, which not only spoils the ending but just isn't all that interesting. Why would I want to watch these two regular guys chat when there's an epic tale of survival going on?
It's too bad because Khan, a veteran Indian actor previously seen in bit roles in "The Amazing Spider-Man" and "Slumdog Millionaire," is very good, expressing the kind of happiness and sadness that such an experience would create. He seems even better when compared to Spall, who says every line with the kind of "Aw, shucks" wonder that can make "Life of Pi" seem a bit too pleased with itself.
Admittedly, though, if I looked as beautiful and as dazzling as "Life of Pi," I'd be pretty impressed with myself, as well.
No Talkbacks for this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Matt Mueller
Published Oct. 1, 2014
The Milwaukee Rep's latest production, the drama "after all the terrible things that I do," deals with some of today's most difficult and challenging modern conversations, ones as a society people are still parsing through - or maybe trying to avoid. Yet that's not what scares the show's lead actors, Mark Junek and Sophia Skiles, going into the show's opening.
Published Sept. 30, 2014
Almost all of the animals in the animal kingdom have the people's care, appreciation and respect ... except bugs. They are annoyances, they are pests and we have no problem brutally murdering them for trespassing on our territory. We have vegetarians and vegans, but very few coming to defend the rights and dignity of little multi-legged critters. Consider writer-director Eric Gerber, the writer-director behind "Pester," one of those very few.
Published Sept. 29, 2014
No matter how much you try to dodge or avoid or fend it off, age comes for us all. But what if it ... didn't? That's the obvious yet unanswerable essential question driving Bill Andrews and Aubrey de Gray, the two scientists at the center of "The Immortalists," the thoroughly compelling new doc currently showing at the Milwaukee Film Festival.
Published Sept. 29, 2014
After working in cheap reality TV for years - including an MTV show called "That '70s House," essentially "Big Brother" or "The Real World" clad in hippie garb - Marquez decided he needed a break from reality TV and wanted to dip his toes into something completely different: actual reality. A decade later, the result is "Psychopath."
Published Sept. 27, 2014
Before his keynote state of cinema lecture at the Colectivo on Prospect today at noon, OnMilwaukee.com got a chance to chat with Wesley Morris - Pulitzer Prize winning film critic and 2014 Milwaukee Film Festival tribute - and pick his brain about his movie memories and - what else - the state of cinema.
Published Sept. 26, 2014
There's something charmingly retro about the tools of the thieving trade on display in "1971," Johanna Hamilton's new documentary that opened the Milwaukee Film Festival last night. However, those tools, plus maybe a few pairs of oversized glasses and some playful period protest cheekiness, are the only things that feel dated about the thrilling, all too timely story "1971" comes to tell.
Published Sept. 26, 2014
Before "Winter's Bone," Jennifer Lawrence was an aspiring actress with a couple of little-seen indie credits and a running TV gig on "The Bill Engvall Show." After "Winter's Bone," she was one of the hottest names in the business. Of course, much of that is because Lawrence is a talented actress, but on some level, she has writer-director Debra Granik to thank.
Published Sept. 24, 2014
A story about concerned citizens stealing FBI info gathered in ethically dubious ways sounds ripped from today's headlines. This particular story, however, doesn't take place now but over 40 years ago, and instead of Edward Snowden's name in middle of the debate, it was a small group of activists called the Citizens' Commission. This all too relevant moment takes center stage in "1971," the Milwaukee Film Festival's opening night selection.
Published Sept. 23, 2014
"The Maze Runner" is a fairly impressive feat: It feels fresh, edgy and exciting - despite the fact that, as the 47th YA adaptation in the last month (a rough estimate), it absolutely shouldn't.
Published Sept. 22, 2014
Cory Chisel currently calls Nashville home, but the folk country Americana rock band leader certainly hasn't cut ties with Wisconsin, the state that he called home for many years before hitting the road and making it big.