For my first blog with OnMilwaukee.com, I wanted to give some background of my views on our K-12 education system. I have been accused of caring only about public education and public schools. For that I plead guilty.
I believe in the importance of the concept of "public," which I define as affecting and pertaining to the community as a whole, being in the service of the community as a whole, openly accountable to the community as a whole, and supported by taxpayer revenue.
In the sphere of education, "public" means free and substantial schooling for all students through the age of 18, equity of resources, serious and challenging intellectual work for every student, with a goal of educating students to become active citizens. Public also means protecting our children's education from profiteers and zealots.
So where do I stand in the vast Milwaukee education "eco-system"? The resources of Milwaukee Public Schools are being drained as more and more students are being recruited to non-public entities, even though the alternative structures show no significant improvement in education outcomes. Instead of calling Milwaukee's K-12 education arena an "eco-system," it should be referred to as a "battleground." Working cooperatively as a Milwaukee community is not on most people's agenda.
Fundamentally at stake is whether we will educate all students or instead select high-performing education for a minority of our children, leaving most to struggle through life without the means to reach the American dream. The practice of modern self-proclaimed reformers is to focus on the few through selection and de-selection processes.
Start with vouchers. This program has been in existence for over 20 years and has only recently been required to make public its test results in order to be compared with Milwaukee Public Schools. Voucher students scored significantly worse than MPS students in math and slightly worse in reading. This is after two decades as an "experiment" at a cost to taxpayers of over $1 billion.
Voucher schools are defined as private institutions and are not required to release data on suspensions and expulsions, staff pay, qualifications, demographics or graduation rates. Students can be expelled or asked to leave voucher schools for any reason.
Voucher schools are independent institutions that have no oversight from a school board or agency of accountability other than the Department of Public Instruction. There is no guarantee that teachers are highly qualified. They are required only to have a college degree, not teaching certification.
Non-MPS charters are given some of the same latitude. There is no unified administration or school board to ensure operational and educational integrity. Schools are individually left to coordinate, plan, carry out staff development and develop resources. The non-MPS charters can also remove students easily – students who, of course, must then be accepted by Milwaukee Public Schools.
Look at the number of students with special needs in voucher schools and non-MPS charter schools and you will see far fewer proportionately than in MPS. Special needs students are the most costly and challenging students to educate.
The practice of selecting and deselecting students with special needs is pervasive throughout the country. For example, Milwaukee's Common Council just recruited a program called Rocketship Education to open a charter school in 2013. Rocketship has three model schools
in San Jose, Calif., that claim huge successes.
Yet at each of these three schools, there are fewer than 20 special-ed students, far less than the San Jose district as a whole that has a special-ed population of more than 12 percent. Why? Keeping the number of special education students below 20 per school means that special education is not considered as a subgroup required to make "adequate yearly progress" under No Child Left Behind.
The practice of not serving special education students or forcing out low-performing students can produce the appearance of successful schools. KIPP charter schools, another national model referred to as "miraculous." have been exposed for similar practices in their attempt to raise test scores. If "behavior problem" students and special education students, who often are challenged by standardized tests, are taken out of the equation, test scores for the school rise.
But such results are hardly miraculous.
If we are going to educate every child in Milwaukee, we must all take responsibility for all children and not allow as a fundamental practice, the selection and de-selection of certain students.
That's what it means to be a supporter of public schools.
This is garbage. The problem with MPS isn't a lack of resources, it is the system itself. I would sure love to see folks from Schools That Can write a few blogs for OMC.
No s***, City. Only an a$$hole who can't stand providing a good education for all would vote for a college dropout for Governor. Clearly, Larry is far different from you.
Show me the other Talkback
6 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Larry Miller
Published Aug. 15, 2012
Tuesday's Democratic primary election in Milwaukee was a victory for public education. Who lost? Democrats who support vouchers, the Republican Party and Tea Party activists.
Published July 16, 2012
MPS is making Montessori education public; accessible to everyone. MPS has been offering Montessori education since the mid-1970s. We are expanding this year by growing MacDowell at Juneau Campus and opening a new school in the old Tippecanoe building.
Published May 30, 2012
This coming Tuesday we will decide Wisconsin's future.
Published May 8, 2012
I recently read Michelle Alexander's book, "The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness." It takes head-on the "elephant in the room" concerning race in America. I feel it is a must read for anyone interested in equality and social justice.
Published April 17, 2012
As an advocate of public education, working for over 80,000 Milwaukee students, my goal is to steer education policy and funding away from privatization, and toward teaching all students with equity in funding and resources.
Published March 21, 2012
Dealing with the aftermath of Walker's horrific cuts has been devastating to our public schools and to the community. And teachers have been at the forefront of the struggle to stand up and reclaim our state. But right now we have to do something to stop the flooding.
Published Feb. 29, 2012
On Feb. 28, over 400 people assembled in the Milwaukee Public Schools central office auditorium in response to a call to action following the recent shooting deaths of four young men, along with other acts of violence witnessed in Milwaukee.
Published Feb. 17, 2012
Recently I had a chance to observe some of these teachers at Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Elementary School. Unannounced, I accompanied the principal into seven classrooms.
Published Jan. 16, 2012
This is reminder to those of you who follow K-12 education in Milwaukee: there's a new plan waiting in the wings that includes another attempt at the takeover of Milwaukee Public Schools.
Published Jan. 11, 2012
What's the real picture on joblessness in Milwaukee? At a conference I attended this past weekend titled OneMilwaukee and sponsored by the NAACP, Mayor Tom Barrett estimated that there are 30,000 people out of work presently and up to 20,000 jobs lost in the city since 2007. He went on to describe the dilemma he faces as mayor.