A post by Richard Florida last week on theatlanticcities.com highlights "The Geography of Stuck," and shows a "distinctive 'stuck belt'" across the middle of the country running from Pennsylvania, Ohio, Michigan, Wisconsin and Iowa, down through West Virginia and into the Sun Belt states of Kentucky, Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana."
Personally, I don't feel stuck in Wisconsin, as I choose to live in Milwaukee and will always call it home. Yet many complain about "Smallwaukee" and the challenges that come with too many long-timers running the show.
Sure, there can be downsides to large numbers of homegrown residents in an area but it's a virtual world and easy, especially in Milwaukee/Chicago, to work with anyone and anywhere.
I haven't done the formal research but I believe in the Midwest and Milwaukee's retention abilities. If you were born here, you usually stay here. Or if you do move away, you usually move back. There's a quality of life in the upper Midwest and the greater Milwaukee area that's hard to match.
I've met Richard Florida several times, and admire him and his work. He's good at packaging his message and I'm sure this "stuck" theme will have some legs. But, Richard, I'm not stuck here, I'm here by choice.
I've stayed my entire life in the Milwaukee area for a lot of reasons. I've never thought that I lacked economic opportunities by being here. The last I checked one can work as a CPA here just as well as one could in Portland.
The Milwaukee area has a lot going for it. We have the amenities of most cities, but it's still a very easy area to move around in. We have very good universities. Our public school system (with the exception of much of MPS) is outstanding. People will complain about the cold weather, but how much would you be doing outside in the Summer if you lived in the South?
And while we've lost some corporate headquarters over the years we still have quite a few major companies that call this area home. As long as they continue to do so the economic opportunities will continue to be here.
My family and I moved here from San Francisco a year ago by choice. We are not from here and have never lived here before. I also have a friend who moved to Milwaukee about a year ago from LA - same story. We love Milwaukee!
Interesting report. Does anyone wonder if part of 'stuck' is the fact that there were high quality manufacturing type jobs.
This recent interactive map by Forbes illustrates the movement of people around the US. It's interesting to compare the movement of individuals in Detroit and Milwaukee to that of more attractive cities like Denver and New Orleans. It's worth a look and, to some extent, confirms the "Stuck" theory.
4 comments about this article.
Post your comment/review now
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Recent Articles & Blogs by Jeff Sherman
Published Aug. 31, 2015
We all need reminders of the importance of keeping the project on pace. So, since it's public record once I submitted it last week, I'm sharing the letter I sent to all members of Milwaukee's Common Council.
Published Aug. 27, 2015
What am I enjoying right now? Other than, of course, my family, faith and friends, the list could get long quickly so I'll keep it to eight. What's on your list? As you think about it, enjoy these.
Published Aug. 19, 2015
It's fun to analyze, pontificate and rank team uniforms and logos. Paul Lukas' latest work on ESPN ranks "uniform attractiveness." Milwaukee falls into his group with two major pro sports teams (NFL, MLB, NBA, NHL). He also does a ranking of the 20 cities with three or more teams.
Published Aug. 12, 2015
To help highlight MMSD Green Luminaries awards, we're focusing on the winners by asking about their practices and new environmental approaches.
Published Aug. 5, 2015
OnMilwaukee.com is once again honored to support Potawatomi Hotel and Casino's Heart of Canal Street program. As a long-time partner and passionate community advocate we're also thrilled to announced that this year we'll help support the Betty Brinn Children's Museum.
Published July 29, 2015
Today, my alma mater - Marquette - helped fuel my fan fire by releasing a new app that is available for free download, thanks to a partnership with Bluechip Athletic Solutions, Inc.
Published July 29, 2015
Children's Hospital of Wisconsin is more than a hospital. It's at the center of an ongoing discussion about health, wellness and access to care for all kids in the state. Today, Peggy Troy talks about the mission, vision, challenges and opportunities at Children's.
Published July 27, 2015
Today I'm writing to ask the members of the state legislature to please vote yes tomorrow for the new Wisconsin arena and entertainment district in Downtown Milwaukee. It's important and vital to our state's long term viability. You should call or email your state representative, too.
Published July 24, 2015
That's right, Downtown Milwaukee may not have a ton of ice cream options but you can order ice cream on demand with #UberIceCream.
Published July 22, 2015
I need a new pair of glasses. I have two pair with my current prescription and one (an awesome SwissFlex frame) with outdated lenses. Yet, I seldom wear either pair other than late at night. This isn't probably the best course for my long term eye health, so I'm on the hunt for a new, cool frame.