In Music Blogs
In Music Blogs


Dylan makes a strong case for "Women and Country"
From the get-go, I'm going to just say right up front that I went to Wednesday night's Jakob Dylan & Three Legs show at The Pabst Theater because of the words "Neko" and "Case."
I've always been lukewarm on Dylan's music as a soloist and as frontman of The Wallflowers. Pleasant enough songs like the much-overplayed "One Headlight" were enjoyable enough but never sent me into spasms of joy.
On the other hand, since the first time I heard an advance of Case's "Furnace Room Lullaby" 11 years ago, I've been hooked and have seen Case in three cities and in a number of different musical settings over the past decade.
If Dylan was hoping that he'd win over some of their crowd by bringing Case and her sidekick Kelly Hogan along for the ride, he was right in at least one case.
Focusing mainly on songs from his latest solo disc, "Women and Country," which features Case and Hogan, and which was produced by no less than T Bone Burnett, Dylan also performed a couple Wallflowers favorites and a smattering of songs from his 2008 solo debut, "Seeing Things."
Opening with "Nothing But the Whole Wide World" -- a song that conjures the melodies of "Tunnel of Love"-era Bruce Springsteen -- it was immediately apparent that Dylan's new songs would get a boost from Case's involvement. And not just because of the simmering quality of her voice, which is so strong that she often had to back two feet off the mic to prevent her harmonies from overshadowing Dylan's low rumble.
No, Case's contribution also came in the form of her extremely strong band, grounded by the acoustic bass of Tom V. Ray and drummer Barry Mirochnick. On these songs, guitarist Paul Rigby and steel guitarist Jon Rauhouse paint in the same haunting hues that distinguish their weighty contributions to Case's oeuvre and provide a different take on the recorded versions that also feature strong musical personalities like guitarist Marc Ribot.
When you learn that Case and Hogan were never bathed in the spotlight -- perhaps it shouldn't be expected since it's Dylan's gig -- you won't be surprised to learn that I thought it was a missed opportunity. If you're going to bring two strong personalities and voices on the road, why not give them each at least one moment to let loose?
Instead, Dylan sort of promised a duet with Case that turned out to barely feature her on "Smile When You Call Me That." Hogan, on the other hand, got one shimmering verse on The Wallflowers' "Three Marlenas," that drew raucous whoops from an audience that appeared clearly hungry for more from the ladies. In fact, Case got the loudest response of all (Dylan included) during band introductions.
Dylan's new songs -- as well as the ones he played from "Seeing Things" -- were a seamless blend of country, folk and roots rock and were almost without exception satisfying slices of pop Americana.
After a 16-song set, Dylan and company returned for a two-song encore that touched on both discs -- "On Up the Mountain" from "Seeing Things" and "They've Trapped Us Boys" from "Women and Country."
With that the almost sedate (read: mature) crowd -- which filled the lower level and spilled up into the mezzanine -- filed out. If they were disappointed at not hearing more Neko they didn't let on. And, while I certainly went hoping to hear more of her, I admit that Dylan impressed me enough that I didn't much regret anything about the evening.
Talkbacks
MStone | April 29, 2010 at 5:59 p.m. (report)
oh and the final song of the set, before the encore is called Lend A Hand.
| Rate this: |
MStone | April 29, 2010 at 5:58 p.m. (report)
Couldn't disagree more. Neko Case's vocals overpowered Dylan's and, at times, didn't even fit the mood of the song. Even the reviewer acknowledges that Case had to step back from the mic at times. I wish she would've stepped much farther back. I think she and Hogan are great on the album but not so much on stage. I didn't go for Case, obviously Case fans want more, and they're going to be disappointed no matter what. I was a little disappointed she was featured so much. Dylan's songs are very powerful and stand on their own. Definitely.
| Rate this: |
israldebruin | April 29, 2010 at 10:17 a.m. (report)
I agree completely. Neko Case was the main draw for me, and I was hoping she'd get more spotlight time... maybe even a song or two from her own catalog. Good show, though. The instrumentation was outstanding. My favorite was probably the final song of the first set... not sure what it was called.
| Rate this: |
jakeyd | April 29, 2010 at 10:14 a.m. (report)
I completely agree with your review. I like Dylan and his new album, but Neko is incredible. I was disappointed she didn't have an opportunity to cut loose. It almost seemed like Dylan offered her a chance, but she seemed content to be the foot soldier at his show. Jakob's voice is too soft to play well live. The performers seemed surprised by the mellow crowd, but it mirrored the songs. I'm going to see the New Pornographers when they come in June, MUST HAVE MORE NEKO!
| Rate this: |
|
4 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review. |
Facebook Comments
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Like Us
Follow Us
















