OnMedia: I have this pet peeve about nuns on TV
Let me start by saying that I was taught by nuns from first through eighth grade at St. Mary's Byzantine Catholic School in Chicago's Back of the Yards neighborhood, the sisters of St. Basil.
Some of the sisters were great teachers, others were not. Some were wonderful human beings, others were not. But all of them were human beings. They were not caricatures or stereotypes, and they weren't cute little elements to put in an advertisement.
I'm not going to make a federal case here, but I am regularly saddened by the use of nuns in TV, a phenomenon that goes back at least as far as Sally Field's ridiculous "Flying Nun," back in the 1960s.
Most recently, there's a Glidden commercial, a cool, colorful way for the paint company to sell its wares with a great Electric Light Orchestra soundtrack. Smack dab in the middle is a group of nuns painting their convent, and then, they magically appear out in the open air, dancing, because, apparently, that's what nuns do when they finish painting.
Here's the Glidden spot I'm talking about:
It's easy to see it as innocuous, but I have a couple points:
Yes, there are nuns who still wear habits, but most do not wear the traditional garb. They are out in society, rather than cloistered as they do their work.
Two, nuns are spiritual women, like many spiritual people in our society -- some of whom do wear traditional garb. Imagine the same scene with dancing men in Hasidic clothing? How about women in Islamic veils?
You wouldn't see it. It would spawn protests at least (not something I'm recommending by any means).
But the trivialization of nuns as cartoon characters isn't seen as insulting to these women of faith.
It annoys me. Not to the level of organizing a protest or calling the Catholic League. I do enjoy a religious joke and I think that religion is a human thing that can be handled comedically. I'm hardly a prude in that department.
But Catholic nuns are not a joke. They're not a device for advertising. They're women who've dedicated their life to a spiritual mission.
All I ask is that their mission isn't obscured by the silly way they're presented on the small screen. There, end of rant.
On TV: The nearest auditions for the next season of Fox's still-hot "American Idol" are June 28 in St. Louis. Here's the complete schedule if you think you have a shot and are willing to travel.
- The second season of HBO's successful "Game of Thrones" will begin filming July 2.
- Discovery Channel is working on a documentary on "SEAL Team 6," which was behind the raid that killed Osama Bin Laden, according to EW.com.
- CBS has picked up Norah O'Donnell from NBC. She'll be the network's new White House correspondent.
- Gov. Scott Walker will guest host CNBC's "Squawk Box" for two hours starting at 6 a.m. Tuesday.
- And I was on Wisconsin Public Radio at 6 this morning talking about media coverage of Weinergate. You can find the audio today at the WPR website.
Stephen Colbert molds the young: Comedy Central's Stephen Colbert addressed the graduating class at Northwestern University, offering his wisdom to a group entering the wider world:
Here's part one of the video (the audio's better than the video):
Here's part two:
Talkbacks
rob | June 21, 2011 at 10:31 a.m. (report)
" But all of them were human beings. They were not caricatures or stereotypes, and they weren't cute little elements to put in an advertisement." thanks for the rant Tim. You rock!
| Rate this: |
tommcmahon | June 21, 2011 at 9:19 a.m. (report)
Spot on, Tim. I have the same view of Whoopi Goldberg's Sister Act. I detest its portrayal of nuns, and I'm not even Catholic.
| Rate this: |
sandstorm | June 21, 2011 at 6:50 a.m. (report)
oh fer chrissakes mkelover. i thought it was only us libs that were so offended by harmless BS like this (as Tim has proven). no one is bashing or even making fun of Catholicism here (btw-i'm Catholic). it's a harmless commercial and, like it or not, nun's habits are synonymous with a sort of seriousness that makes it somehow funnier to see nuns dancing (but, no, not THAT funny). replace the nuns with people in Islamic garb and most people would be asking "wtf", not getting angry. please explain to me how Catholics are being bashed or made fun of in this commercial. kinda makes me wonder if babies are getting a little PO'ed at being "bashed", exploited, and made fun in those E-trade commercials.
| Rate this: |
mkelover | June 20, 2011 at 1:08 p.m. (report)
It's become perfectly acceptable in this society to make fun of or otherwise bash Catholicism. But don't you DARE make fun of any relgion like Islam or you'll have to go to sensitivity training for weeks. It's almost like bashing middle-age men in advertising, completely acceptable.
| Rate this: |
|
4 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review. |
Facebook Comments
Disclaimer: Please note that Facebook comments are posted through Facebook and cannot be approved, edited or declined by OnMilwaukee.com. The opinions expressed in Facebook comments do not necessarily reflect those of OnMilwaukee.com or its staff.
Like Us
Follow Us
















