Milwaukee's Daily Magazine Friday, Sept. 5, 2008
Today
Hi: 68
Lo: 54
Sat
Hi: 68
Lo: 56
Sun
Hi: 75
Lo: 57
Section Sponsor
Article Tools
Print this Article
Make text larger
In Marketplace Blogs
Dog DNA test is for the birds
What kind of dog do you think Playa is?
By Andy Tarnoff RSS Feed
Publisher

E-mail author | Author bio
More articles by Andy Tarnoff

What is a blog?  For us it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Published Jan. 9, 2008 at 2:22 p.m.
Tags: dna, mexico, dog

It's a regular exercise around my house to speculate on the breeds that make up my mutt, Playa, the dog we brought back from Mexico in 2003. Any time we bring her to the dog park, someone will inevitably ask what kind of dog she is, since she looks so different than your typical pooch. Until now, we speculated that she is mostly whippet, which is a small greyhound. In fact, we've seen Playa standing next to whippets, and from her bony little feet to wasp-shaped body to her long tail, she's very close in appearance.

Her personality, too, is similar to whippet: shy and skittish, but loving and calm when she gets to know someone. But she also looks and acts a little like all the dogs we met in Mexico, and it's clear that she's many generations removed from a purebred specimen.

So when I took Playa into the vet for some booster shots in November, I found myself intrigued and excited that a company called Mars Veterinary has created a DNA test they dubbed the "Wisdom Panel MX." Their literature claimed it could detect hundreds of breeds from a single blood test, ostensibly to teach owners more about their dogs. In fact, their slogan is "Because different breeds have different needs." I thought this seemed like a great idea, both to learn more about any of Playa's physical specificities that might come in handy down the road -- and truthfully, to satiate my own curiosity.

The test ran about $160, and I figured it was a small price to pay for the answer to this four-year-old question. About three weeks later, the vet informed me of the results, and today I picked up the official paperwork.

Both the vet and I agree that this Mars Veterinary group might as well have picked two breeds out of thin air. Or maybe they tested a different dog.

The test, which allegedly screened for DNA from hundreds of breeds, came back with only two: a "significant amount" of Belgian Malinois and a trace amount of "Bichon Frise."

No greyhound, whippet, labrador, terrier or even Chihuahua. Even the vet seemed puzzled, and called her rep at Mars Veterinary. They stood by their claim.

I'd never heard of a Belgian Malinois, but it's generally a police dog that resembles a German Shepherd. It's a tough and aggressive work dog that, I guess, looks a little like Playa in its hind legs (although, by that classification, every dog looks a little like a Belgian Malinois.)

The Bichon Frise, on the other hand, shares no characteristics with Playa, physically or behaviorally. Other than being a dog, neither the vet nor I could see any similar traits.

And that's it. The vet agreed that the results seemed spotty, at best, and warned that the DNA testing was far from perfected.

That much, we can agree upon.

But Mars Veterinary promised way too much with its not-so-wise "Wisdom Panel." If it weren't for the amusing blog fodder, I'd feel like I flushed my $160 down the drain.

Honestly, the test left me a little bummed out -- and more importantly, it taught me a lesson. I supposed I wanted proof that Playa is a portion whippet, or lab, or anything. The test, even if it's accurate to a certain extent, reaffirms that my dog is one of a kind.

She's the way she is because, even though she was born in "captivity," her parents lived on the tough streets of Isla Mujeres. Because Playa spent her first four months living among dozens of other dogs, all unsocialized with humans and fighting for food. And she's here because we brought her home, from the beach to Milwaukee.

Belgian Malinois, Bichon Frise or hyena, whatever her DNA says she is, Playa is our special dog: one-of-a-kind as a breed and totally special as a member of our family.



More Information ...
Related links:

2 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.

Recent Talkbacks ...
Posted by Preview
booboo16 Thanks for the info...I was thinking of getting that done on my new pooch, but ...
a_noid Does OMC want to do some investigative reporting? My dog Otis was rescued from ...

Recent blogs/briefs by Andy Tarnoff
What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Brett is back (but only in my dream)
Wednesday
Laugh if you must, but I had an incredibly vivid, realistic dream last night ... about ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. The angriest e-mail I've ever received
Tuesday
I didn't expect to get this scathing e-mail over a 5-year-old review of the puzzling Elton ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Ten terrific years of OnMilwaukee.com
Monday
It was exactly 10 years ago today when we flipped the switch and launched OnMilwaukee.com. ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. McCain throws in the towel with vexing veep pick
Friday
John McCain just lost the election, days before the Republican National Convention even ...

What is a blog?  For OMC, it is a short blurb that we write when the mood strikes us.  It can be first person, funny or informative. In short, a blog is whatever we want it to be. Harl-eh ...
Aug. 29, 2008
I have to admit that I'm somewhat underwhelmed by the Harley reunion. As much as I was ...