Milwaukee's Daily Magazine Thursday, July 24, 2008
Today
Hi: 80
Lo: 65
Fri
Hi: 84
Lo: 70
Sat
Hi: 85
Lo: 63
Section Sponsor
Article Tools
Print this Article
Make text larger
In Dining
Milwaukee gradually grasps pizza by the slice
Thanks to a few new pizza places, Milwaukee can finally grab a slice to go.  
By Julie Lawrence RSS Feed
OnMilwaukee.com Staff Writer

E-mail author | Author bio
More articles by Julie Lawrence

Last updated Dec. 7, 2007 at 5:27 a.m.
Tags: pizza, slice, classic slice, hotch-ado, meglio pizzeria, pizza shuttle, times square pizzeria


Note: The contents of this guide were checked for accuracy when this article was updated on Dec. 7, 2007. We continually update the thousands of articles on OnMilwaukee.com, but it's possible some details, specials and offers may have changed. As always, we recommend you call first if you have specific questions for the businesses mentioned in the guide.

Milwaukee, like most cities, has never really had any sort of pizza shortage. Whether it's the classic cracker-thin crust from Zaffiro's or Pizza Man you like, the thicker, doughy version at Pizza Shuttle or Joey Buena's deep-dish, there has always been a plethora of pie options.

But unlike many other large metropolitan areas, Milwaukee has somehow been massively devoid of pizza slices to go. In cities like New York or Chicago, you can hardly go a block without passing an opportunity to grab a slice, but that's not been the trend here -- with a few exceptions over the years -- until recently.

"Everywhere that I have ever lived or traveled to had at least one good slice shop," says Marisa Lang, owner of Classic Slice restaurant, which opened in Bay View in spring, 2007. "A place that you could bring the family, a date, or eat solo on your way to see a band -- I longed for Milwaukee to provide the same experience."

Acting on her vision for a place to get a good salad, a slice and a beer with "no frills or huge time commitment," she opened her slicery -- you can also get full pizzas, calzones and bread sticks, too -- to help fill the big gap in the quick eating market.

There are a handful of other restaurants and delis around town that are doing their part to make Milwaukee a slice city, as well.

Classic Slice
2797 S. Kinnickinnic Ave.
(414) 238-2406

myspace.com/classicslice
To give you an idea of how huge these slices are, only one slice can fit into a 12-in. pizza box. As owner Lange says, "Only the brave order two." Every slice is essentially it's own creation, so each is made to order with any of the restaurant's available sauces, cheeses (including soy) and toppings.
Slice price: $3.50 for cheese, .50 each topping

Hotch-A-Do
1813 E. Kenilworth Pl.
(414) 727-2122

hotch-a-do.com
Hotch-A-Do makes its own pizza dough on a daily basis from the family recipe of owner Angie Storm. The organic-oriented restaurant doesn't serve actual slices, per se, but it does offer individually-sized six-in. pizzas of any variety.
Slice price: $5, $3 additional topping

Meglio Pizzeria
1888 N. Humboldt Ave.
(414) 272-1888

megliopizza.com
This pizzeria opened in summer 2007 in the first floor of a new condo development. By the full pie, you can get just about any variety your taste buds desire, including Hawaiian, cheese steak and BBQ chicken, but when it comes to the single slice, Meglio stays traditional with cheese, cheese and pepperoni or cheese and sausage offerings.
Slice price: $3.95

Metro Market
1123 N. Van Buren St.
(414) 273- 1928

mkemarketplace.com
The deli at this Downtown grocery store is always hopping during the lunch hour, no doubt in part to the excellent pizza slices with equally as excellent prices. The cheese, cheese and sausage and veggie -- which is loaded with green and red peppers, onions and mushrooms -- varieties all come with a medium-thick crust and are all the same low price.
Slice price: $1.99

Pizza Shuttle
1827 N. Farwell Ave.
(414) 289-9993

pizzashuttle.com
The slices here are infamous for their uber thick and doughy texture, topped with a generous supply of homemade sauce. Call in advance for if you're curious about the slice of the day, but the Shuttle is almost always stocked with plenty of the classics -- cheese, pepperoni, sausage, pepperoni and sausage.
Slice price: $3.99

Times Square Pizzeria
605 S. 1st St.
(414) 224-6300

Times Square also opened in '07 to dish slices to the traveling masses. Daily offerings include pepperoni, sausage, pepperoni and sausage, margherita (olive oil base topped with tomato and basil), cheese and an ever-changing specialty 'za. Times Square earns extra pizza points for serving a warm, buttery, flaky roll with each slice.
Slice price: $3.25

Whole Foods
2305 N. Prospect Ave.
(414) 223-1500

wholefoodsmarket.com
Alongside the jumbo calzones and panini at Whole Foods' hot prepared foods area are freshly wood-fired slices with cheese, cheese and pepperoni, as well as a couple specialty surprises. One is enough for lunch, but the price cut at two is a good deal if you're looking for tomorrow's lunch, too.
Slice price: $2.99 or two for $5

5 comments about this article.
Post a comment / write a review.

Recent Talkbacks ...
Posted by Preview
danno I wish pizza places would offer a range of pizza sauces because some like sweet ...
curlyboy1978 Murphy -- I am glad you mentioned Rocky's! I dont know how the author forget ...
murphy What about Rocky's? I mean they don't have the best pizza but they've been serving ...
TosaJimBob Try Cranky Al's on 69th and North avenue in Wauwatosa! Great pizza! You can ...
mrjohn Hey West Siders!! JOHNNY V's on Hwy 100 between National & Oklahoma serves up ...